People ask “proxy or VPN” when they need a middleman between the phone and a site and are not sure which of the two to take. The short answer: a proxy passes the connections of the programs configured for it, while a VPN on Android creates a virtual network interface, and all of the device’s traffic or that of chosen apps goes through it. Below, in more detail, based on the Android documentation and RFC 1928 (read on 21 November 2026): encryption, trust, choice and a check.
In short. A proxy is a middleman for individual programs: it works only if the program is configured for it. A VPN on Android is a system service: the app creates a virtual network interface, and the system routes into it the packets of the whole device or of chosen apps. Encryption is a separate question: it comes from a specific protocol and method, not from the words “proxy” or “VPN”. Pick a proxy when you need one program and trust whoever runs the proxy; pick a VPN when you need to cover the whole phone, for example on public Wi-Fi. We did not compare proxy and tunnel speed.
We make Mayak. We make a VPN app for Android; we do not name or rate other proxies or services. 3 days free, no card needed.
🍎 On iPhone Mayak works with the subscription link from your account. INCY was removed from the Russian App Store on 27 October 2026: if you already have it, it keeps working — do not delete it, it cannot be downloaded again from the Russian store right now. With a Russian Apple account, Clash Mi and Shadowrocket are available now (we have not verified them live with our link); Happ and INCY need an Apple account of another country.
The difference in one table
| What is compared | Proxy | VPN on Android |
|---|---|---|
| What goes through the middleman | Connections of the programs configured to use it | The packets the system routed into the tunnel: the whole device or chosen apps |
| Who sets it up | The program itself or a system network setting | The VPN app; on first start you confirm a system window |
| Encryption | Depends on the kind of proxy and the authentication method | Depends on the protocol, not on the word “VPN” |
| Whom you have to trust | Whoever runs the proxy | Whoever runs the VPN service |
What a proxy is
A proxy is a middleman at the level of a program: it sends a request not directly but through someone else’s server, and the server passes it on. There are HTTP proxies and SOCKS proxies. The SOCKS version 5 protocol is described by RFC 1928: it is a “framework for client-server applications in both the TCP and UDP domains” and “does not provide network-layer gateway services” (section 1). Put simply, a proxy passes the connections of programs, not all the packets of the device.
Android has a system proxy setting for a network (for example, for Wi-Fi). According to the developer reference (the ProxyInfo class), proxy configurations are “already integrated within the java.net and Apache HTTP stack”, and those libraries use them automatically; “other HTTP stacks” need to obtain them themselves. The practical conclusion: a program may not read this setting and go direct. The system proxy setting is a request, not a compulsion.
What a VPN on a phone is
On Android a VPN is an app that the system has allowed to pass traffic through itself, through the VpnService service. The developer reference describes it like this: it “creates a virtual network interface, configures addresses and routing rules, and returns a file descriptor to the application. Each read from the descriptor retrieves an outgoing packet which was routed to the interface.” The app then exchanges packets with the remote server over a tunnel.
The same reference has two requirements that protect you: user action is required the first time an app creates a VPN connection (the request window), and a system-managed notification is shown while the connection lives. So an app cannot turn a VPN on silently. More on what that window is in the article “What a VPN is and how it works”.
Encryption is a separate question
Neither the word “proxy” nor the word “VPN” on its own guarantees that traffic to the middleman is encrypted. RFC 1928 shows this directly: the authentication methods in SOCKS 5 include “no authentication required” (code 00), GSSAPI and username/password, and protection of integrity and confidentiality depends on the negotiated method; the security section says it is highly dependent on the methods a particular implementation provides. What a VPN app does behind the scenes is likewise decided by the protocol, not by the name.
The general rules we repeat here, not opening anything new: if traffic to the middleman is not encrypted, it can be seen along the way; with an HTTPS site, the content is protected by the site itself; and in any case the middleman knows where you connect. So the question “whom do you trust” matters equally for a proxy and a VPN; we have an article on VPN safety.
What to pick
- A proxy, if you need one program or browser, the program can work through a proxy, and you understand who runs the proxy and what it sees.
- A VPN, if you need to cover the whole phone at once, including apps that cannot use a proxy; on public Wi-Fi (we have a write-up on public Wi-Fi); on a TV or set-top box if the programs you need have no proxy setting.
- A VPN, but not for everything, if some apps should go direct. On Android there is per-app splitting for this: in our app it is called “Split tunnel” in “Settings” (three modes: all apps, all except chosen, only chosen). More in the article on split tunnelling.
A check: where the traffic goes
- Note your address. Open any service that shows your IP address, before connecting.
- Turn the middleman on and check the address in a browser.
- Check from another app. If the address there stayed the same, it is a proxy for one program, not a tunnel for the whole phone. If the address changed for the apps and the system shows the VPN notification, the traffic goes through a tunnel.
- Look at the notification. While the VPN is on, the system shows it, and you can disconnect from it.
More about the address and leaks: “How to check that a VPN works: five minutes”.
See it on yourself. The difference between a proxy and a VPN is easier to see once than to read: during 3 free days check your address from a browser and from other apps and look at what the system notification shows.
What happens next.
- Create an account in the dashboard: email and password, no card.
- Install the app: from Google Play or as a file from our site. On first connection Android shows a connection request window: that is as it should be.
- Press one button and check your address from several apps, as described above.
🍎 On iPhone Mayak works with the subscription link from your account. INCY was removed from the Russian App Store on 27 October 2026: if you already have it, it keeps working — do not delete it, it cannot be downloaded again from the Russian store right now. With a Russian Apple account, Clash Mi and Shadowrocket are available now (we have not verified them live with our link); Happ and INCY need an Apple account of another country.
How it is with us
Mayak is a VPN app for Android: it works through VpnService, on first connection Android shows a request window, and splitting by app is switched on in “Settings” → “Split tunnel”. That is what our pages say; on speed and on how our paths are arranged we have separate articles with measurements (speed tests, connection time).
What we do not promise
- That a proxy is faster than a VPN or the other way round: we did not compare them.
- That any particular service or program will work through a proxy or a VPN.
- That the description above fits every proxy and every VPN: different programs have different protocols and settings.
What we checked
- The Android documentation on
VpnService(virtual network interface, user action on first connection, system notification) — 21 November 2026. - The Android documentation on
ProxyInfo(the system proxy setting is integrated intojava.netand Apache HTTP; other HTTP stacks must read it themselves) — 21 November 2026. - RFC 1928 (SOCKS V5): purpose, authentication methods, encapsulation for confidentiality, the security section — 21 November 2026.
- Our own pages: how the Mayak app works through
VpnServiceand where its “Split tunnel” is.
What we do not know
- The speed of a proxy and a tunnel on the same network: we did not compare them.
- How a proxy behaves inside a particular third-party program: each has its own implementation.
- What a particular third-party middleman does with traffic: that is in its terms, not in our article.
- The legal side: we explain how the technologies work and give no legal assessment.
Short answers
How does a proxy differ from a VPN? A proxy passes the connections of programs configured for it; a VPN on Android is a virtual network interface into which the system routes the packets of the whole device or of chosen apps.
Which is better, a proxy or a VPN? For one program and with trust in whoever runs the proxy, a proxy will do; for the whole phone, public Wi-Fi and apps with no proxy setting, a VPN. Neither is better in general.
Does a proxy encrypt traffic? Not necessarily: it depends on the kind of proxy and the method; under RFC 1928 the “no authentication” option is part of the SOCKS 5 standard.
Does a proxy hide my address? For a program that goes through the proxy, a site sees the proxy’s address. For programs that go around it, no. Check your address from several apps.
Is Mayak a proxy or a VPN? A VPN app for Android: it works through the VpnService service, and splitting by app is switched on in “Settings” → “Split tunnel”.